Difference between Accounting Profit and Economic Profit

Economic Profit vs. Accounting Profit: An Overview

Profit is a concept that’s often talked about in business, but its meaning can sometimes seem a bit fuzzy. When we think about profit, we usually imagine the money left over after a company pays all its bills and expenses. However, there’s more to it than just that.

Accounting profit is calculated by subtracting expenses from revenue, giving us a straightforward number to work with. But when we dive deeper into economics, we uncover a different perspective. Economic profit takes into account not only explicit costs like rent and wages but also implicit costs such as the opportunity cost of using resources. This means economic profit gives us a more comprehensive understanding of a business’s true financial health, considering both what’s visible on the balance sheet and what might be hidden beneath the surface. Let’s explore the differences between accounting profit and economic profit to see why this distinction matters in the world of business.

Table of Contents

What is Accounting Profit?

Accounting profit represents the straightforward calculation of a company’s earnings based on its financial statements. It is the difference between total revenue and explicit costs, including explicit expenses such as raw materials, labor costs, rent, and utilities. In simpler terms, accounting profit is the revenue generated by a business minus its explicit costs.

Formula for Calculating Accounting Profit

Accounting profit is a measure of a company’s profitability that considers only explicit costs, such as wages, rent, materials, and other expenses. The formula for calculating accounting profit is straightforward:

Accounting Profit = Total Revenue – Explicit Costs

Here’s a breakdown of each component:

1. Total Revenue: The total income generated from selling goods or services.
2. Explicit Costs: The actual expenses incurred by a business, including costs such as wages, rent, utilities, raw materials, advertising, taxes, and other operational expenses.

Accounting profit provides a more straightforward assessment of a company’s financial performance compared to economic profit, as it does not account for opportunity costs or other implicit costs. It is commonly used in financial reporting and analysis to evaluate a company’s profitability.

An Accounting Profit Example

Let’s consider a simple example of a small retail business selling handmade crafts.

Let’s say the business generates a total revenue of $10,000 over a period of time by selling its crafts.

Now, let’s break down the explicit costs incurred by the business during the same period:

1. Cost of materials: $2,000
2. Wages for employees: $3,000
3. Rent for the store space: $1,500
4. Utilities (electricity, water, etc.): $500
5. Advertising expenses: $300
6. Taxes: $200

To calculate the accounting profit for this retail business, we use the formula:

Accounting Profit = Total Revenue – Explicit Costs

Accounting Profit = $10,000 – ($2,000 + $3,000 + $1,500 + $500 + $300 + $200) = $10,000 – $7,500 = $2,500

So, the accounting profit for this retail business during the period would be $2,500. This means that after covering all explicit costs, the business earned a profit of $2,500 from its operations.

Limitations of Accounting Profit

While accounting profit provides a useful measure of a company’s financial performance in terms of explicit costs, it has several limitations:

Ignores Implicit Costs: Accounting profit does not consider implicit costs, such as the opportunity cost of using owner’s capital, time, or resources. This can lead to an overestimation of the company’s profitability since it fails to account for the true economic cost of resources.

Ignores Non-Monetary Factors: Accounting profit focuses solely on monetary transactions and does not consider non-monetary factors such as customer satisfaction, brand reputation, employee morale, and environmental impact. These factors can significantly affect the long-term success and sustainability of a business but are not captured in accounting profit.

Subject to Manipulation: Accounting profit can be manipulated through various accounting methods, such as revenue recognition policies, depreciation methods, inventory valuation methods, and expense categorization. This manipulation can distort the true financial performance of a company and mislead stakeholders.

Short-Term Focus: Accounting profit typically reflects the financial performance of a company over a specific period, such as a fiscal year. However, it may not provide insights into the long-term sustainability and growth potential of the business. For example, investments in research and development or employee training may not immediately impact accounting profit but could enhance future profitability.

Does Not Reflect Cash Flow: Accounting profit is based on accrual accounting principles, which recognize revenues and expenses when they are incurred, regardless of when cash actually flows in or out of the business. Therefore, accounting profit may not accurately reflect the cash flow position of a company, which is crucial for its liquidity and solvency.

Limited Comparability: Accounting profit may not be directly comparable between companies due to differences in accounting policies, industry norms, and business models. This can make it challenging for investors, analysts, and other stakeholders to assess the relative financial performance of different companies accurately.

What is Economic Profit?

Economic profit, also known as economic surplus or pure profit, accounts for both explicit and implicit costs associated with a business endeavor. It represents the excess of total revenue over total opportunity costs, including both explicit and implicit costs.

Formula for Calculating Economic Profit

Economic profit is a measure of a company’s profitability that takes into account both explicit costs (such as wages, rent, and materials) and implicit costs (such as the opportunity cost of using resources for a particular endeavor). It is calculated by subtracting both explicit and implicit costs from total revenue. The formula for economic profit is:

Economic Profit = Total Revenue – (Explicit Costs + Implicit Costs)

Here’s a breakdown of each component:

1. Total Revenue: The total income generated from selling goods or services.
2. Explicit Costs: The actual expenses incurred by a business, including costs such as wages, rent, utilities, raw materials, etc.
3. Implicit Costs: The opportunity costs associated with resources owned by the firm, such as the foregone income from alternative uses of the firm’s assets, including the owner’s salary if they could earn more elsewhere.

Economic profit can be positive, negative, or zero. Positive economic profit indicates that the business is generating more revenue than the combined explicit and implicit costs, while negative economic profit indicates that the business is not covering all its costs, including opportunity costs. Zero economic profit means that the business is just covering all its costs, including opportunity costs, and is earning exactly the same return as it would from its next best alternative use of resources.

An Economic Profit Example

Let’s consider an example of a small software development startup.

Total Revenue: $100,000 Explicit Costs:

• Employee salaries: $50,000
• Office rent: $20,000
• Utilities and other operational expenses: $10,000
• Materials and equipment: $15,000

Now, let’s calculate the implicit costs:

The owner of the startup, who is also the founder and primary developer, could have worked as a software engineer at an established company and earned an annual salary of $80,000. However, instead of doing so, the owner decided to invest their time and expertise into starting their own business.

Implicit Costs: Opportunity cost of owner’s salary: $80,000

To calculate economic profit, we use the formula:

Economic Profit = Total Revenue – (Explicit Costs + Implicit Costs)

Economic Profit = $100,000 – ($50,000 + $20,000 + $10,000 + $15,000 + $80,000) = $100,000 – $175,000 = -$75,000

In this example, the economic profit of the software development startup is -$75,000. This indicates that the business is not covering all its costs, including the opportunity cost of the owner’s time, and is experiencing a net loss.

Key Differences Between Accounting Profit and Economic Profit

Accounting profit and economic profit are two important concepts in economics and finance that measure the financial performance of a business. Here are five key differences between them:

1. Calculation Method: Accounting Profit is calculated by deducting explicit costs (such as rent, wages, utilities) from total revenue. It’s the straightforward calculation used in financial accounting. On the other hand, Economic profit considers both explicit costs and implicit costs (opportunity costs). Implicit costs are the opportunity costs of using resources in a particular venture rather than in their next best alternative use.
2. Treatment of Implicit Costs: Implicit costs are not considered in accounting profit calculations. It only focuses on the explicit costs incurred by the business. Economic profit considers both explicit and implicit costs. It accounts for the full cost of utilizing resources, including the opportunity cost of using resources in a certain activity versus their next best alternative.
3. Long-Term vs. Short-Term Perspective: Accounting Profit typically focuses on short-term financial performance and is concerned with the monetary gains or losses made during a specific accounting period. Economic profit considers the long-term implications of business decisions. It evaluates whether a business is truly profitable after considering all costs, including opportunity costs, over the entire life cycle of the business.
4. Use in Decision Making: Accounting profit is primarily used for external reporting and taxation purposes. It provides stakeholders with a snapshot of a company’s financial performance. Economic profit is more useful for internal decision-making processes. It helps managers assess the true profitability of projects or ventures by considering all costs and benefits, including opportunity costs.
5. Indicator of Economic Efficiency: While accounting profit is important for assessing a company’s financial health, it may not provide a complete picture of economic efficiency since it ignores implicit costs. Economic profit provides a more comprehensive measure of economic efficiency. By accounting for implicit costs, it reflects whether a business is truly adding value above and beyond the resources it utilizes.

Conclusion

While accounting profit serves as a useful measure of a company’s financial performance, it only provides a partial picture of its true economic value. Economic profit offers a more comprehensive assessment by accounting for both explicit and implicit costs. By understanding the differences between these two concepts and their implications, businesses, investors, and policymakers can make more informed decisions that drive long-term success and economic prosperity.